Nachtigall scored both UW-Oshkosh goals as the visiting Titans edged Concordia University (Wis.), 2-1, on Sept. 19. Nachtigall helped UW-Oshkosh erase a 1-0 halftime deficit by scoring twice during the first 20 minutes of the second half. He recorded the match-winning goal on a penalty kick in the game's 65th minute (64:18). Nachtigall tied the score at 1-1 during the 54th minute (53:03) of play. His goal followed a cross from Tony Starnes and a touch pass from Ryan Redmond.
Also nominated:
UW-Platteville, Keith Baerwald, Freshman, Forward, Elkhorn, Wis.
UW-Superior, Brian Grand, Junior, Forward, North Branch, Minn.
UW-Whitewater, John Gottwald, Junior, Midfielder, South Milwaukee, Wis.